TL;DR
Why do so many health system strategic plans look great in the board book and change so little on the ground?
In our experience it is rarely because the analysis was wrong. It is because the people who have to carry out the plan never truly agreed to it. The CMO nodded. The CNO had concerns she did not voice. Two hospital presidents left the retreat with different ideas about what had been decided.
Choosing the right strategic planning facilitator is how you prevent that.
Large systems face pressures that make planning sessions unusually difficult:
A skilled facilitator turns those pressures into an agenda the group can actually work through.
| Type | What they bring | Best when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Healthcare strategy consultancy | Market analysis, benchmarking, service-line strategy | You need the analysis built for you | The plan becomes the consultant's plan, not your team's |
| Healthcare governance specialist (for example, Via Healthcare Consulting) | Board and medical staff governance expertise | The core issue is board roles or medical staff structure | Less depth in running large multi-group planning sessions |
| Process facilitation firm (for example, Leadership Strategies) | Neutrality and a proven method for reaching agreement | You have the data but need real alignment and decisions | Make sure they will learn your context through interviews first |
Many health systems combine two: a consultancy for the analysis and a facilitator to lead the sessions where decisions get made. For a side-by-side look at firms that run hospital leadership retreats, see our comparison of external meeting facilitation firms.
We use the 6 Ps of Preparation to design every strategic planning session we facilitate. They also make an excellent interview guide:
A facilitator who answers all six with specifics is selling an outcome. One who starts with the venue and the icebreaker is selling an event.
Our approach comes from Michael Wilkinson's book The Executive Guide to Facilitating Strategy, and it follows a simple arc:
Throughout, we keep three running lists, Issues, Decisions and Actions, so nothing agreed in the room is lost on the way back to the office.
Many systems try. The challenge is that a leader cannot facilitate and participate at the same time. When the person running the session is also a senior voice, others edit what they say, and the plan reflects the loudest opinions rather than the best ones. An outside facilitator lets your strategy leader do what they are best at: contributing to the content.
The cost of a facilitator is small next to the cost of a plan your leaders do not own.
Planning your next strategic plan?
Leadership Strategies has specialized in facilitation since 1993. We run hundreds of facilitated sessions a year, and our bench includes 11 of the world's 56 Certified Master Facilitators. We will interview your stakeholders, design the session around the decisions you need, and document every commitment.
They design and lead the planning sessions as a neutral party. That includes interviewing stakeholders beforehand, building the agenda, guiding discussion and conflict, and documenting the vision, priorities, goals, owners and dates the group agrees to.
Hire a consultancy when you need market analysis built for you. Hire a facilitator when you need your leaders to agree on what to do with the analysis. Many large systems use both.
Typically system executives, hospital presidents, physician and nursing leaders, key operations and finance leaders, and in some sessions board members. A good facilitator will help you balance representation against group size.
It varies with scope. A typical process includes several weeks of interviews and preparation, one or more facilitated sessions, and follow-up sessions to finalize goals and measures.
Assign an owner and a date to every initiative, agree on a small set of measures, and schedule regular progress reviews before the planning session ends.